Skip Navigation
 

Brazil, A Buying Opportunity?

<%=_author %>

By

Padraig O'Hannelly

From the Fool blog

How To Bag A Bargain This Christmas

Published in Investing on 20 June 2008

After a fall of nearly 10%, is this an opportunity to buy Brazil?

Even after a fall of nearly 10% in recent weeks, the Brazilian market is a still a star performer, having gained over 20% in the past year.

What's driving Brazil?

In a word: commodities. As a gross generalisation, within the BRIC economies, Brazil and Russia provide the materials, China and India use them up. Consider the following:

  •   Brazil is the worlds biggest exporter of coffee, soybeans, chicken, beef, sugar, and orange juice;
  •   Almost twice the size of the EU, less than 7% of its land is arable, but unproductive land is being irrigated and converted into farmland -- yes, they are making more of it. Much of this development is uncontroversial, but there are environmental and ethical considerations in some regions;
  •   Water is a commodity too, and is key to agricultural development. Brazil has more of available water than any other country, almost 80% more than nearest rival Russia. Less than 1% of Brazil's water is currently used;
  •   According to some reports, Brazil is already a net exporter of oil, and there are considerable finds still to be developed. Proved oil reserves are 13.9bn barrels (17th in the world), and exploration is continuing. The state-controlled oil giant Petrobras is planning to build two new refineries, one of which will cost $11bn;
  •   Brazil is also home to Vale, the world's largest producer of iron ore.

How is the economy performing?

Growth is expected at 4.7% this year, even as the government struggles to keep inflation within its target range of 4.5% +/- 2%. To achieve this, interest rates were increased to 12.25% earlier this month.

This interest rate is not as painful as it would be in UK, as levels of personal debt are pretty low, and people generally prefer to save to buy a house rather than borrow.

The currency, the Real, has been appreciating against other currencies as exports are booming.

What about Brazilian politics?

When President Lula Da Silva was first elected in late 2002, there were concerns that his Workers' Party would be hostile to private industry, and the stock market reacted accordingly. In practice, he has been generally pro-business, has not overspent, and has been tough on inflation.

The country's debts have been reduced, and are now rated as investment grade by ratings agencies. There are currently plans to establish a sovereign wealth fund.

As regards commodity-rich emerging markets, many investors regard the Brazilian regime as much less capricious than Russia's.

How expensive is the Brazilian market?

After the recent fall, the Bovespa Index is trading on a multiple of about 16, so considerably more than the FTSE's 11.4, but not outrageous if you accept the argument that Brazil is a long-term winner.

How can I get exposure to Brazil?

One of the easiest ways is through Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs); a popular one is iShares MSCI Brazil (LSE: IBZL) , in which investor Jim Slater has a significant stake. You can find a listing of Brazil-related vehicles at Trustnet.

I'm bullish on Brazil, but for balance you should bear in mind a local saying quoted by another Brazil fan, Jim Rogers:

"Brazil is the next great country in the world, always has been, always will be."

You could buy a Brazil ETF via Motley Fool Sharebuilder and pay commission of just £1.50.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

TMFCoffeePot 20 Jun 2008, 10:26pm

Those who entered the brazilian market 5 years ago could get brilliant profits. From 2002 to now the IBovespa index soared 700%. Now some people say that 'the party is almost over', that the market has become expensive to get in.

I don't know, I am a software developer, not an investment expert, but I think the usual advice applies... to buy the index for the long term seems to be a good bet. And of course, we can't expect returns like those from the last 5, 6 years.

I am a buyer of the IBZL etf myself. But only for 20% of what I invest, and I don't plan to touch the investments for the next decade.

the pros that I see: food, oil, mining and energy sectors, water and an internal market with plenty of room to grow.

cons: deficiency in infrastructure, education, incompetence in public spending, a tax system that is 'heavy' and too complex to understand, a high level of violence/crimes on the main cities... things that can definitively affect the economy.

pennysworth 22 Jun 2008, 7:40pm

As a long-time resident of Brazil (27 years on and off since 1970!), I have pretty much seen it all in this country - military dictatorship in the 1970s, hyperinflation in the 1980s, price freezes, wage freezes, you name it! So I still feel a bit gippy when it comes to investing in the markets here.

As long as global demand for commodities exceeds supply, Brazil will probably continue to be a good place to invest. However, much as I hate to be a doomsayer, maybe this is another bubble waiting to burst. The last six years have indeed been very profitable ones for investors in IBOVESPA listed companies, and money from abroad continues to pour into Brazil, with the result that the Real has been rising and rising in value against all the major currencies. In November, 2002, 1 UK pound bought nearly 6 reais; today, you'd be lucky if you can get 3!!

The private sector is booming, but the largely corrupt and inefficient public sector continues to be a millstone round the economy's neck. An annual increase of 4.7% may sound fantastic by European standards, but it would be much higher with a leaner and more efficient public sector.

mahdave 23 Jun 2008, 1:17pm

I tend to heed to the man-on-the-spot generally because he really sees what is really there.BUT at the same time a picture from a reasonable distance gives you a face or scenre, whereas the same seen from three inches away allows you to see a few "pixcels" not the full picture.
In short, I am still confused but oil, commidities, food are definitely the base on which next 20 years are going to be built.SO, I will use my system to (1) wait and see during June/July 2008 (Bad patch) and BUY thereafter.(2) Take a ride therafter and (3) Take some profits (if any) during Feb.2009 and remaining in November same year. Numerology is my main guiding light.

bepem 23 Jun 2008, 3:02pm

23/06/08:
Brazil is physically very far off for personal investors. Even if we can invest via LSE, investor relationship in the urgency of the matter could be time and financially intolerable.
On-line access ends by dealing, but dividend cheques, corporate action deadlines, cash payable or receible will depend upon postal transit in the long run. Many things need to be reviewed in advance for the working culture of the business operators, which we might not do from the armchair in London or Kitwe. Local paying agents might exploit on individuals helplessness by asking premium service charges.

Join the conversation

Instructions

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: <b>bold</b>, <i>quoted text</i>. All other tags will be removed from your post.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.