Skip Navigation
 

A Simple Answer To Britain’s Debt Crisis

Cliff D'Arcy

By

Cliff D'Arcy

From the Fool blog

Where To Invest In 2009

Published in Get Out Of Debt on 29 August 2008

The answer to our national credit crisis is both remarkably simple and intensely painful…

Last week saw the release of I.O.U.S.A. in American cinemas. Just as former Vice-President Al Gore’s ‘An Inconvenient Truth’ warned of the coming environmental catastrophe, so I.O.U.S.A. reveals that America faces a financial crisis of truly epic proportions.

The film warns that the US is buckling under the weight of its $9.5 trillion national debt, vast budget and trade deficits, and negative personal-savings ratio. (You can view the YouTube trailer for I.O.U.S.A. here.) Of course, our cousins across the Big Pond aren’t the only society addicted to the ‘spend now, pay later’ way of life. In fact, on some measures, British consumers are now deeper in debt than our friends across the Big Pond...

I Owe UK

At a national level, the UK faces similar problems to the US. Thanks to rising government spending and the nationalisation of Northern Rock, our national debt is set to exceed Chancellor-turned-Prime-Minister Gordon Brown’s ceiling of 40% of gross domestic product (GDP, a measure of national income and output). Indeed, our national debt triples when you add in £200 billion of Enron-style, off-balance-sheet Private Finance Initiative (PFI) debt, plus a further £750 billion to fund guaranteed pensions for public-sector workers.

Just like the US, the UK continues to build up a sizeable annual budget deficit. Indeed, government spending is expected to exceed tax revenues by perhaps £50 billion in the 2008/09 financial year. In addition, thanks to the steady decline of British manufacturing, we now import far more goods than we export. Thus, like the US, we have a substantial trade deficit with the rest of the world, and are hooked on cheap imported goods.

We’re slightly better at saving...

Then again, British adults are a little better off than their American counterparts when it comes to personal savings. In the US, the savings ratio (which measures the proportion of take-home pay which is saved) turned negative some time ago. In other words, American adults are draining their deposit accounts, rather than shoring up their savings.

Here in the UK, the savings ratio has remained positive since the late Fifties. Alas, as I revealed in Who Stole Our Savings Habit, it fell to a 49-year low of 1.1% in the first quarter of this year. In other words, we now save just £1 in every £90, which is nothing to write home about. However, I hope this ratio will begin to rise as we Brits rediscover the virtues of saving.

...but far worse at borrowing

When it comes to mortgages and other personal debt, we Brits are head and shoulders above our European neighbours. Indeed, during our seemingly never-ending housing boom, personal debt more than tripled, as the following data demonstrate:

(£bn)

Jun 95

Jun 08

Change

Change (%)

Mortgages

383

1,212

829

+216

Other debts

65

232

167

+257

Total

448

1,444

996

+222

Source: Bank of England

As you can see, we Brits have borrowed almost an extra trillion pounds in the past thirteen years. Around five-sixths (83%) of this extra borrowing is mortgage debt, which shot up as house prices rocketed. However, our non-mortgage debt (such as credit and store cards, car and personal loans, and overdrafts) has also exploded, and now averages roughly £9,000 per household.

What’s more, according to money education charity Credit Action, our debt burden increased by around £98 billion in the past twelve months, or almost £1 million every five minutes. Today, our debt mountain is costing British borrowers nearly £95 billion a year in interest alone, or over £300 per household per month. Ouch!

The simple answer: better budgeting

In my view, our vast increase in personal debt is merely a symptom, not a disease in itself. Our underlying problem is blindingly obvious: we’ve become accustomed to spending more than we earn. Indeed, millions of households routinely spend £110+ for every £100 of take-home pay. Of course, constantly living beyond your means is the road to financial ruin.

Thus, the answer to our national credit crisis is both remarkably simple and intensely painful. The government and individuals must stop spending tomorrow’s money today. In other words, we need to tighten our belts, cut back and live below our means. Otherwise, the scale of our problem will continue to increase, placing an intolerable burden on future generations.

In summary, my rallying cry is: Wake up, Britain and mend your spendthrift ways in order to avoid future financial meltdown!

More: Learn how to Get Out of Debt | Who Is To Blame For Debt Crisis? | Current Discounts And Deals #68

> Visit our Living Below Your Means and Dealing With Debt discussion boards

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

bimber 30 Aug 2008 , 2:44pm

Well said.

MonsterMixer 31 Aug 2008 , 4:04am

Greetings!

The problem with a sharp adjustment in saving habits is that it would bring around a capitulation in economic activity (consumption and investment), leading to unemployment and decline, directly proportionate to the change in savings ratio.

This is what Keynes meant by the "Paradox of thrift".

Quite simply there is only one feasible way out of this mess - inflate away the debt through loose monetary policy - an "inflation surprise". This acts as a tax on savings, and erodes the real value of debt.

It would also erode the price of housing in real-terms while encouraging nominal price rises.

MontyPorridge 01 Sep 2008 , 8:38am

It is quite true and quite simple. My old granny used to say £1 income and £1 and sixpence (£1.025) expenditure = misery, £1 income and 19shillings & 6pence (£0.975)expenditure = happiness. Even Margaret Thacher had that attitude to UK finances. Simple and pragmatic. It was she who negotiated the rebate from the EU that Blair gave away.
But we should not be concerned. After all we have been told ad nauseam how Brown is the best Chancellor ever and a financial wizzard of epic proportions and that any prosperity we had was all his doing regardless of world conditions. Brown is still there, for now, so we will be just fine thank you very much. Won't we?

TimeValue 01 Sep 2008 , 9:14am

Whilst I agree that everyone needs to live within their means the problem as a bit bigger than that now. MonsterMixer at 4:04 is probably frighteningly close to the truth of what will happen. The government have lied to us for years.
Ever increasing debt is not an economy. We have to get the whole country producing added value. We have millions on benefits doing nothing except working the shadow economy. We have to close the gap between the rates of pay for unskilled people and the benefits. Perhaps we could increase national minimum rates to say, £10/hr and simultaneously simply stop in importing people. If there is an incentive to work people will respond. The arguments used to justify the bonuses of financial sector gamblers applies just as well to an 18 year old, unskilled semi-literate from the Easy Durham coalfield.
We also have to stop stomping around the world pretending to be a world power. We have token armed forces with second rate equipment. Yet we have morons like Milliband drawing on his virtual jackboots at the first opportunity (wonder if he drives a German car?).
We have to stop pretending we are the font of all knowledge and saviours of the world; we can't even manage our own problems.
Let's get back behind our own borders, and concentrate on our own problem Oh, and stuff Europe. It's a big French benefits club, Germany's apology for its past deeds. Why do we fund it?
I could go on but I'm sure we all can.

Terrapin1 01 Sep 2008 , 10:11am

We are ruled by an elite band of thugs who tell Dubya what to do.
They want to destroy the envirnoment and enslave their people with the credit habit. The US must stop producing cars for at least 2 years, and get rid of the $ multi trillion backlog of unsold new and s.h. cars. UK is just the puppy dog.

bojotools 01 Sep 2008 , 10:16am

Britain is still very much a world power in every sense of the phrase. Our pathetic infrastructure at home and lack of skills in our workforce have long been carried by overseas earnings in service industries and fields such as aerospace and engineering. We still have some of the best engineers and designers in the world and we should not forget that Britain is a massive investor in the USA and China with many Chinese companies being British owned and managed. Problems stem from our education system which at it's best is producing world-renowned captains of industry but on average is turning out unemployable drones who could not change a fuse. Sort out the lousy teachers tied in knots teaching subjects which have no use in the real world, teach life skills and promote science and engineering and the UK will eventually turn around at home.

NatFeerick 01 Sep 2008 , 2:05pm

I can instantly think of spending our government could cut - stop waging wars against other countries then we can cut the military cost, stop giving money to other countries and re-direct the money to the poverty-stricken in this country, stop paying huge salaries to useless civil servants who leave confidential reports on trains. That should help the budget deficit - any more ideas???

db2dba2 02 Sep 2008 , 2:48pm

bojotools - Blame the teachers for the credit crunch??? Blimey that's a tenuous link if ever there was one. The only people to blame for the state of the UK are the people who've been at the top for the last 20 years. They are the ones who have encouraged, even forced, people to get into debt so that they can do normal things like buy a house, get an education, etc. As for captains of industry, why would they give a toss as long as they are feathering their own nests? These are the people who make the decision to cut jobs in the UK and send them offshore in order to 'compete' (and get themselves a fat bonus into the bargain).
The sad fact is I don't care how good your scientists or engineers are, they can be replaced more cheaply elsewhere.

rowlystravel 02 Sep 2008 , 5:32pm

living within your means is a good long term idea in theory, unfortunately, the whole ecpnomy is based on the fact that easy credit has been available to buy anything we want and Britains prices reflect this, i.e. they are higher than elsewhere, even accounting for VAT...

This country is unneccessarily expensive and it is pure greed.. a simple example is the humble Pizza, in this country a 14'' pizza on thick bread (bad) with minimal topping cost well over £12 - 14.. in italy the same pizza would be on thin bread with large amounts of topping at no more than 6 euros... the only discrepancy in the price is greed and that sums up the UK...

Even the head of Centrica said there is no money in windfarms and renewable, hence they are putting their prices up as much as they can to fund its investment before they start losing a fortune and selling off the company in pieces

Britain is Greedy.. so the simple lesson we really need is not to live within our means, but to all stop being greedy and trying to make more money than neccessary of others, and thats people and companies alike...

thanks for listening

Gostevie 03 Sep 2008 , 4:25pm

Ah, Cliff, so THAT'S how you cleared your £50,000 debt then!

:-)

asiequana 04 Sep 2008 , 11:45pm

Hmm. Household debt went up, mainly due to mortgages? What happened to home prices during that time? What do you think is going to happen to home prices going forward? I am willing to bet outstanding mortgage debt, and therefore overall household debt, will decline going forward. Any takers?

churchill123 12 Sep 2008 , 3:01pm

Monstermix quites Keynes effectively. The pronblem with his solution is that we have seen what the 'inflation surprise' does to the economy. It happened here in the early 80's (23%!!!) it's happening in Zimbabwe now and it ahppened to germany in the 1930's.

We have insufficient Gold reserves to buy back our currency to maintain it's trading value, so what he suggests would ultimetly lead to complete financial ruin and embarresement for the UK.

Is he mates with Gurrdun Broon?

EZEpZ 12 Sep 2008 , 3:17pm

Suggestion to anybody who may be concerned about where its going.
Think outside the box.
Dont worry about living within your means and limiting yourself, forgettting your 'dreams' and accepting 'reality'
Lets have a campaign for common sense!Increase your means. Yes its possible, Ill prove it to anyone interested enough to respond!
x

churchill123 12 Sep 2008 , 8:34pm

Life coaches can save the economy?

emptybarrel 15 Sep 2008 , 10:27am

I agree with MonsterMixer that a sharp withdrawal in credit will lead to a painful recession. However a contraction is necessary.

As a nation we need to re-focus on what our major assets and resources are for generating an income in a world of global competition. I believe one of these is culture. We already have a good track record of exporting culture in the form of our history, popular music, art, media , sport etc. This is an area we should concetrate on. We should also examine the exporting of freshwater supplies to arid countries of the world. Manufacturing can return to Britain, it is after all the cheapest source in terms of transportation costs, but it need's to use advanced robotic tools to produce complex products at a lower cost than mass Chinese labour.

Nemo666 21 Sep 2008 , 10:25am

What worries me is that the last time there was a major industrial country, that ignored human rights and locked people up in internment camps without a trial or access to the legal system (guantanamo bay), had a corrupt undemocratic system where the majority didn't vote (and some bent the rules to rig elections - Al Gore lost when he shouldn't have), had powerful armed forces that ere used to invade other countries to access resources (Iraq) then we had WW2 - Germany in 1939 had to invade its neighbours as they couldn't pay the national debt and decided it was cheaper to invade and take resources

Role on the National Socialist States of America. They even are threatening Russia now over Georgia. Oh come on! I can't help but think that sabre rattling is the perfect excuse to throw money at defence again. Then when you have a big stick what do you do with it when you can't afford it anymore? Use it or lose it.

War also takes peoples minds off of problems at home. Iran may be in trouble soon :(

crazybucks1 23 Sep 2008 , 2:31pm

I'm from the US. We have our heads in the sand here. I live in a area where industry is pulling out left and right, houses are up for sale street after street, social programs are losing funding. And as of this writing, due to Hurricane Ike, we experienced a week long power outage, long gas lines and high food prices. Yet, my neighbors are are not adjusting. Not planning on what is next. Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, AIG, Freddie and Fannie should be a wake up call for what will eventually be a down hill spiral.People simply need to cut back, stop using credit cards, stick to necessities until they can see a clear path. Then save and pay as you go. If you can't afford it, don't buy. Live simply and be happy.

dymafieto 31 Oct 2008 , 11:00am

When it is stated in the article above that "millions of households routinely spend £110+ for every £100 of take-home pay" does "spend" here include their regular mortgage payments?

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.