Skip Navigation
 

Don’t Rely On This ‘Safety Net’

Laura Starkey
By Laura Starkey | 21 July 2008

As the cost of living in the UK continues to soar, it’s no wonder some of us are finding our bank accounts bare by the end of each month.

While going into debt to make ends meet is hardly ideal, unsecured lending statistics suggest many of us have edged into our overdrafts during the past year.

But what if you’re reliant on being in the red for a few weeks each month, and your bank decides your overdraft days are over?

Cuts

A couple of weeks ago, TMF HQ received a call from a site user who was shocked -- and stressed out -- by his bank’s decision to drastically cut his overdraft limit.

There was little warning or explanation for this. Although the man’s balance was within his existing overdraft limit, it was higher than his new limit -- which, rather laughably, his bank informed him had been set with a ‘buffer’ in place!

After scouring internet forums and discussion boards, I realised this reader wasn’t alone. Perhaps as a result of the credit crunch, several banks seem to be calling in overdrafts -- in some cases, ones that have been in place for years.

Then, I found my own overdraft completely cancelled -- never mind cut!

According to the letter I received, I had 30 days to repay the full amount. After that, any overdrawn balance on my account would be subject to the “usual tariffs”.

Roughly translated, that meant I could face punitive unauthorised borrowing fees and sky high interest charges if I didn’t clear the debt. Yikes!

When I asked my bank why, they informed me I had not credited the account with enough payments over the previous 12 months and was therefore in breach of its terms. However, it’s been more than two years since I paid my salary into that account -- so I was surprised to be so unceremoniously reminded of the rules.

My overdrawn balance was relatively small, so I paid it off last week using a credit card balance transfer.

But I can’t help feeling concerned that people with larger debts would face a much tougher challenge in similar circumstances.

Overdrafts In Theory

To get a better idea of how banks view their provision of overdrafts, I spoke to the British Bankers’ Association, the Financial Services Authority and the Banking Code Standards Board.

In theory, an overdraft is a flexible form of borrowing which allows a user to get on top of temporary cash-flow problems.

As you can withdraw cash from an overdraft in the same way you take out your own money, you can supposedly ensure that you only borrow what you need -- and you’re free to pay it back whenever you like, with no penalties.

Moreover, overdrafts are generally fast and free to arrange -- another boon if you’re headed for choppy financial waters and need a quick fix.

The vast majority of banks state in their terms and conditions that an overdraft facility can be revoked at any time.

Due to the ‘impermanent’ and ‘informal’ nature of overdrafts, they’re not regulated in the same way as credit cards or personal loans under the Consumer Credit Act.

Overdrafts In Practice

Unfortunately for borrowers, overdrafts do not always operate in the way they are supposed to.

I have a close friend who’s been consistently overdrawn in her graduate account by over £1,000, for more than four years! It doesn’t take a genius to see there’s nothing about this arrangement that implies it’s ‘temporary’.

However, she’s at risk of having her overdraft facility cancelled at any time -- and she’ll have little recourse to complain.

Some overdrafts are allowed to persist far beyond their theoretical ‘stop-gap’ role. This almost certainly suits the institutions that provide them, as overdraft interest rates tend to be far higher than the rates on personal loans -- or even credit card debts -- of equivalent size.

Unfortunately, while it can seem to provide the consumer with a semi-permanent income ‘extension’, an overdraft is an expensive, insecure and unpredictable way to borrow.

What Can I Do If My Limit Is Cut?

If you’re informed your overdraft is soon to be cancelled or cut, you should contact your bank immediately.

If you allow your balance to stay negative past the overdraft cancellation date, it’s likely you’ll be hit with bank charges -- and these will push you further into the red.

Also, under the terms of the Banking Code most institutions should arrange a repayment plan or ‘reducing overdraft’ for you, based on what you can afford to pay them back each month. If they don’t offer you this lifeline, ask for it.

Even better, consider transferring your overdraft balance to a 0% credit card -- a move that could massively reduce your interest payments and help you move far faster towards clearing the debt.

And don’t forget, being overdrawn doesn’t preclude you from switching banks. Alliance & Leicester's Premier Current Account is a top choice for anyone overdrawn. Switchers will receive a £100 sign-up bonus, and an overdraft at a typical rate of 0% for 12 months. However, if your overdraft is more than £1000, it may not be fully matched in your new account -- and this offer does not apply to existing Alliance & Leicester customers.

If, like many others, you’ve become accustomed to ignoring the little minus sign in front of your bank balance, now could be the time for a re-think.

Getting over your overdraft might be tough, but it can be done…

And, bizarrely, without this supposed ‘safety net’, your finances could feel far more secure.

More: How To Beat Overdraft Charges |Use This Credit Card To Clear Your Overdraft

> Compare current accounts via Fool.co.uk

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool.

At 09:04 on July 23 2008, mickgjames said:

Recently heard of a bank cancelling the overdraft of someone who'd been unemployed and on income support for three years. Charming.

At 10:30 on July 23 2008, lunastate1999 said:

I'm with Smile and they called me a while back to say that they were cancelling my £960 overdraft. Instead of them demanding that this was cleared within 30 days or so, they very kindly offered to reduce this by £60 per month, which is enough to make a difference but not enough to make a noticeable impact on my monthly cashflow. It's great to see the overdraft coming down now, and every month I'm in the black for a couple more days with just that little bit less debit interest to pay. It's quickly coming down and will be cleared by March '09. Good stuff Smile!

At 17:32 on July 23 2008, susancs said:

Are we talking about Natwest, among others, by any chance? I was recently informed by Natwest my overdraft facility was being withdrawn "as I had not used the account during the past year". This is not my main current account, but I had transferred money into it in early June and direct debits were being paid as they came due, so I don't understand how Natwest could say it wasn't being used. I wasn't aware there was a minimum usage requirement. Having written to the author of the letter at their "Customer Lending Office" (so much for the TV ad hyping their branch facilities), copied to my branch, to suggest a lower overdraft facility, I have had the courtesy of precisely zero response from either the author of the original letter or my branch. Needless to say, if I have my Natwest current account closed, I will also close my less-than-competitive savings account with them.

At 15:17 on July 24 2008, Plasticbabe said:

Ironically, about six months ago I asked for my overdraft limit to be decreased and was told that this was fine, but on the criteria in place I could have £1000 to £1250. I thought at the time that it would be too tempting to dip into it, so I asked for it to be cut to £250. Unfortunately, last week I found myself in the position of needing to borrow £500 temporarily (for about a week), quickly and cheaply - I could have paid by credit card, but did not want to incur the extra charge for this. Barclays then told me that they couldn't extend my overdraft at all because of my poor credit score. I find this slightly worrying, given I haven't missed any payments or anything!

At 11:40 on August 08 2008, Vincenzo30 said:

Hi Plasticbabe - I suspect your bank was referring to their own 'credit scoring'. All banks rate their customers based on the products you hold with them, the money that goes through your accounts etc. The criteria vary. It is unlikely they would have run an independent credit check in this instance.

This is a case in point though of why, as a general rule, you should avoid giving up credit facilities, even if you don't need them.

Join the conversation

Hello stranger. Please [log in] to comment.

Not yet registered? Register now.

 

Switch to a different topic area

Can't find what you need in Get Out Of Debt? Try one of our other personal finance areas.

Latest stories

Get all the latest news and editorial comment as it's published – check out our Fool Articles

Discussion boards: Dealing with Debt

Recent posts: